RBS Six Nations 2012: Scotland Player Ratings v Italy

15 – Stuart Hogg 6
One of two Scottish backs who looked most likely to score a try. Made a few breaks through the line, however did not really pose any danger until the last twenty minutes, when Scotland woke up a bit.

14 – Max Evans 5
Would have perhaps had more impact if he had played in the centre position. On the wing he saw little of the ball.

13 – Nick De Luca 4
Had a solid opening 30minutes, however was sent to the bin in the 38th minute for a deliberate knock on. Following that he was quiet and failed to threaten the Italian line.

12 – Graeme Morrison 6
The other back that looked most likely to score a try, and his closest moment came when he was chasing down his own kick. Slight moment of fisticuffs in the first half. But failed to ignite the rest of the backs.

11 – Sean Lamont 5
What a difference a week makes: last week Lamont was full of energy and drive, this week however

10 – Greig Laidlaw 5
Lacked the control that Scotland needed from this position. Landed 2 penalties, but missed one as well.

09 – Mike Blair 5
Tried to exert the control that Laidlaw did not, although ultimately failing. Not quick enough clearing the ball from the base of the ruck, thus slowing Scotland’s game down.

01 – Jon Welsh 4
With Allan Jacobsen pulling out in the warm-up, Welsh was thrust into the limelight and struggled against the power of Martin Castrogiovanni.

02 – Ross Ford 5
Better in the set piece, but still not up to scratch. Uninspiring from the captain, who really needed to step up to the mark and lead his team. Instead he appeared dispirited and disheartened.

03 – Geoff Cross 4
Very quiet, and had little impact upon this game.

04 – Richie Gray 5
Not even the poster boy could pull a good performance out of this game. He seemed just as dispirited as everyone else on the team.

05 – Jim Hamilton 5
Slightly contentious sin binning in the 55th minute, and a handbags moment early on in the game. These incidents aside, Hamilton came to attention only for a few fumbles in the set pieces.

06 – John Barclay 5
The experienced head in a back row that has caused a stir this competition, Barclay was unable to show his younger counterparts how it was done, as the Italians gave him little opportunity to impact.

07 – Ross Rennie 5
Anonymous showing from Rennie in this game, not of the same calibre as his hard hitting, hard tackling, style we have seen before.

08 – David Denton 5
Not a performance that matched up to the ones he has put in in the previous matches as Italian captain Sergio Parisse showed him up.

16 – Scott Lawson: not used

17 – Euan Murray (Cross, 49mins) A strategic change in order to add strength to the scrum. It worked to an extent, but the Italians still dominated.

18 – Alastair Kellock (Gray, 54mins) Normally a vocal force on the pitch, Kellock has usually been one of the better replacements. But was as anonymous as the rest of the team.

19 – Richie Vernon: not used

20 – Chris Cusiter: not used

21 – Ruaridh Jackson (Laidlaw, 69mins) A fly-half in the fly-half position for the final eleven minutes of the game did nothing to change Scotland’s fortunes.

22 – Jack Cuthbert: not used

5 thoughts on “RBS Six Nations 2012: Scotland Player Ratings v Italy

    1. I thought this, as in the ground they announced Walsh had replaced him, but since returning every site i have looked at said Jacobsen, so I’ve been scratching my head!

      1. They are all mistakes Welsh started the game as Jacobsen was injured in the warm up. Incredibly disappointing the Rugby Blog did not pick up on this and proceeded to rate Jacobsen.

  1. View from the game:

    Gray hurt himself after 10 minutes and was having a fitness test when we arrived at the ground as well, I would suggest he wasn’t fit. Hogg was the only man to look like he was really bothered.

    It was a really woeful performance from Scotland and most of the Scottish fans I talked to afterwards actually said that it was the worst they had seen too, going back over many years. Italy weren’t much better to be honest.

    If I were to mark the game, it would get a 1/10, it really was that bad. The ground and atmosphere were completely different though. 72000 people made an incredible din in a great ground with a wonderful setting, particularly the Peroni Village.

    Rome is definitely THE away day in the 6 Nations now, though Scottish fans may disagree.

Comments are closed.