
Watching Leicester Tigers’ victory over Gloucester the other weekend, I was struck by a man-of-the-match performance by centre Matt Smith. The 31-year old, one-club stalwart was immaculate; he organised the backline, made 14 tackles himself, and delivered the kind of unselfish performance that has been typical of his career. His work allowed the supposed stars of the backline – guys like George Ford, Matt Toomua, Telusa Veianu, Jonny May and Nick Malouf – the space and time to put Gloucester to the sword in the first 30 minutes.
Matt Smith’s career has not quite delivered the prestige of his colleagues in the backs – a solitary appearance for the England Saxons, the pinnacle of his recognition outside the Tigers. In the weeks after the Tigers’ recent run of victories, the official social media accounts were full of clips of bone-shaking hits by Toomua, or the dancing feet of Veianu and the electric pace of May. Smith may not generate the clickbait highlights, however, over the past 11 years, and 200-plus appearances, you could argue there has been no-one more important, and no one more devoted, to the East-Midlands club.
I would say it is no coincidence that Leicester’s backs have been playing some brilliant rugby since Smith has been occupying the 13 shirt on a regular basis. It may seen a leap to mention the Tiger in the same breath as another Smith – Conrad – but he is filling a similar role for Leicester that C. Smith did for the All Blacks. He is the glue which knit the group of super-stars into a cohesive unit. He may lack ‘ol snake hips elusive poise and eye for a break, but Matt’s teammates know his value.
There are players like Smith all over the Premiership. They may not receive the column inches and universal acclaim like some, but they are worth their weight in gold to the teams they represent week in, week out.
Chris Pennell of Worcester Warriors is another of those players. He probably has the shortest international rugby career in history (as far as my research can tell), his solitary England cap coming in the 79th minute of the first test of England’s 2014 tour of New Zealand – but as another one-club man, Pennell has been a brilliant player for Worcester since his debut in 2007.
Prior to that England call up, Pennell had been in astonishing form. I remember watching the Warriors play Leicester and thinking Pennell was trying to win the game single-handedly for them. It was a mark of his quality that he nearly succeeded.
What is even more admirable about Pennell is he followed relegated Worcester down to the Championship after having just made that international debut. Although Stuart Lancaster and the England coaches indicated at the time they would continue to monitor Pennell, despite playing in the second tier (although I have my doubts about that, given international coaches often hold not playing in the Champions Cup against a player), he never earned a recall – although injury played a part. This was the year before the World Cup and there were certainly no shortage of suitors for Pennell among the top clubs. For a player on the fringes of the international setup to sacrifice his personal career and miss out on potentially being part of a World Cup is as surprising as it is noble.
Pennell was right back to his best last weekend – a rare shining light for Worcester so far this season. He is a wonderful player to watch and rightly appreciated by his club’s supporters – but you can’t help think he had more to offer at the highest level.
That Exeter are now Premiership champions and that Phil Dollman’s class is not more widely recognised is a sad state of affairs. Unlike Smith and Pennell, Dollman may not have been a one-club player (he started his career with Newport Gwent Dragons), but he is still a long-standing servant for the Chiefs – clocking up 150 appearances over 8 years since joining them in the Championship.
Dollman is a hugely versatile player – slotting in with ease at wing, fullback or in the centres. He (alongside Ian Whitten, another under-appreciated player) is the core of Exeter’s backline and has been essential to their tilt at the title – he has filled in wherever needed, steering them through promotion to the Premiership, those first forays into European rugby, and culminating in that victory over Wasps at Twickenham in May this year.
There Dollman lined up opposite Willie le Roux, a unanimously agreed world-class fullback, yet it was Dollman who came out on top: Dollman who scored the try, Dollman who ended with a Premiership winner’s medal.
He earned a surprising call up to the Welsh squad after the season ended for the tests against Tonga and Samoa. At the age of 32, he is hardly one for the future but it was a deserved reward for a wonderful player in the form of his career.
Who are your club’s unsung heroes that deserves greater recognition?
By Henry Ker
Supporting Saracens there are a couple of players who have never received the recognition they deserve; but whom never have ever let down the club and have been integral to the success the club has had. Which, with the international call ups that Saracens will cope with, makes these players roles all the more important:
1. Richard Barrington has understudied Mako Vunipola for a number of seasons now and always puts in a great shift. Stepping from Jersey was a huge step but one he’s done brilliantly.
2. Jackson Wray is probably the most consistent back row forward in the premiership over the last three or four seasons. Covering 6,7 and 8 has probably unfairly typecast him as a utility player, and therefore not given him the international recognition he deserves. Certainly those of us who see him week in week out would pick him ahead of other utility back rowers.
3/4 Brad Barritt is the leader and captain who has led the club to the heights it now reaches. And in combination with Marcelo Bosch makes maybe not the flashiest centre combination but almost certainly one of the most effective.
5. Chris Wyles. Mr dependable from 12 to 15. And a nice guy to boot.
Jeremy,
I am pretty sure that Brad Barritt receives the deserved recognition, certainly amongst those who understand the game.
I do agree that Jackson Wray os probably typecast as that utility player and probably suffers for that. Possibly in a similar vein to Matt Garvey and Matt Banahan at Bath.
For me, its got to be James Lunn at Bank RFC. Bruising ball carrier and deft hands. He gets my vote over an old, past it , and Leiceter ‘A’ player at best Matt Smith.
An interesting article and question. Everyone will have their own personal choices for this one, but as a Sarries fan I would have to second Jeremy’s choice of Jackson Wray. He was the first person I thought of when I read the heading. He has been at the club man and boy and rarely makes a mistake.
Going further back I would say that Kevin Sorrell would fit into this category in his playing days. Barely missed a tackle and similarly to Matt Smith, allowed other players to shine.
I’ll throw in for Jackson Wray as well – shame he’s never won a cap
I think Pennell could have had a great England career but as you say he was a victim of injury timings and playing for an unfashionable club
Other names that spring to mind, past and present:
George Lowe at Harlequins
Carl Fearns at Bath
Alex Lewington at Irish (who also followed his club into relegation)
To Jeremy, Dazza and Pablito – I will agree with Jackson Wray as well, I was originally going to talk about him as well but felt I had rambled on long enough!
I wouldn’t surprise me if Lewington steps out of this category pretty soon. He seems to be the shining light at Irish so far this season.
Hope so. At least time is on his side. Think he’d be in EJ’s plans if he hadn’t taken the drop with Irish
Lewington is definitely a good shout! Great for Irish week in week out.
Dave Ward is another one at Quins whether at hooker or flanker.
Loved watching Fearns for Bath; such a brute. And was really disappointed when he left, especially when Burgess then also left.
He’s now thriving at Lyon and is close to becoming eligible for France. A loss to England imo.
I agree, a beast of a back row.
Felt he was very poorly treated over the Burgess debacle and it was a disappointment that no other English clubs picked him up.
Felt less sympathetic when he reneged on his Gloucester deal
But at the end of the day, he’ll always have a special place in many rugby fans’ hearts for laying out a mouthy Gavin Henson…
Henry Trinder? Great talent, unlucky with injuries
Mark Lambert is one of the most underrated props in the premiership in the loose and set-piece and George Lowe was always brilliant too tho’ that’s said by a Quin’s man.
Pennell, Lewington and maybe Dom Barrow?
Harry Thacker is always great too but often overlooked (no pun intended.)