From the archives: European dominance bodes well for neglected Ireland


As we head into the final round of the Heineken Cup pool stages, things are looking good for the Irish provinces. Come the end of the weekend, they should have three teams through to the knockout stages (barring any aberrations at home from Leinster or Munster), while even Connacht have a mathematical chance of qualifying if they can recreate the miracle of the Ernest Wallon at Allianz Park.

With that in mind, is it fair to say Ireland should be considered amongst the favuorites for the Six Nations? Below is an article from 2012 arguing just that, in a year when the provinces dominated the Heineken Cup once again. On that occasion, Ireland could only finish third in the Six Nations, falling to disappointing losses to Wales and England, and drawing with France. Do they have a better chance this year?

Article below first published Jan 23rd, 2012

“With three sides through to the Heineken Cup quarter-finals for the first time ever, there is no doubt who the dominant force is at club level in Europe right now. Yet following last year’s Rugby World Cup, all the talk has been about RWC finalists France and a resurgent Wales to win the RBS Six Nations 2012.

The results from Rounds 5 & 6 though will force people to think again with regards to their predicted champion. Munster, Ulster and last year’s champions Leinster have all progressed to the knockout stages, and will all be involved in two home Irish games, with Munster taking on Ulster at Thomond Park. Munster and Leinster were also the top two seeds at the end of Round 6, whilst Ulster produced one of the performances of the season last week at home against Leicester.

Statistically speaking, between the three of them they have been superior against each nation’s teams; against English opposition they have won five matches and lost just once, against the French they have won four, drawn once and lost once, whilst Munster completed a double over the Scarlets in the only Irish-Welsh pairing. Furthermore, in the last two weeks, Ulster and Munster scored 92 points against two of England’s playoff contenders in Leicester and Northampton. Leinster, arguably the best of the three sides, also scored 52 points against Bath in Round 4, creating an aggregate of 144-70 over the three games. That’s before remembering that Connacht defeated Premiership leaders Harlequins on Friday night.

Naturally, there are some counter-arguments. Supporters from other nations will highlight the influence of foreign players in all three sides, who of course are not eligible to play for Ireland in the Six Nations. Isa Nacewa at Leinster, Ruan Pienaar, Johann Muller and John Afoa at Ulster, Lifiemi Mafi and BJ Botha at Munster. But the truth is the majority of all three starting XVs were dominated by Irish players, who in turn make up most of Declan Kidney’s squad.

What’s more, six or seven players who put in outstanding performances over the last weekend are not yet in the senior squad, such as Chris Henry, Eoin O’Malley, Dan Tuohy, James Coughlan, Luke Fitzgerald and hat-trick hero Simon Zebo. The key lies in Kidney not only managing to get all of them to gel together, but to also be bold and select on form rather than reputation. If they can get that right, it could be Ireland’s year.

by Ben Coles

Photo by: Patrick Khachfe / Onside Images

One thought on “From the archives: European dominance bodes well for neglected Ireland

  1. I’d go further and say there was nothing unique about 2012 against the other seasons in the last 5 years. Irish clubs have often looked the best in Europe, stuffed with Irish internationals. Those same players have not been able to dominate the international stage. A lot of people point at coaching/selection and therefore believe this is now solved. A lot of other people (me included) think that Welsh/English/French club results seem to not be linked at all to international performance so why would the Irish be any different?

Comments are closed.