
For the first time in 2015/16, teams from Europe’s top leagues were given a breather from domestic competition this weekend and turned their attentions to the Champions and Challenge Cup tournaments. After the horrific events that unfolded in Paris on Friday night, the matches scheduled to be played on French soil were postponed and so here is an abridged round-up of the results.
Premiership sides enjoy Round 1
The first match-up in the premier European competition involved Leicester and Stade Francais on Thursday evening, and the performance of the Tigers set the tone for the Premiership teams that followed over the weekend. While it was Stade who drew first blood with a show-stopper of a try from Julien Thomas, Leicester’s control of the set-piece gave them plenty of opportunities to hit back, which they eventually did through Niki Goneva and Matt Smith before half-time. Tries from Paul Williams and Julien Arias were not enough to keep Stade Francais within touching distance as Leicester crossed twice more, with Brendon O’Connor snatching up a loose ball and sprinting fifty metres to score, and Ben Youngs weaving through for a vintage scrum-half effort. With a 33-20 victory, and standout performances from Youngs and O’Connor under their belt, Richard Cockerill will be delighted with his team’s start to European rugby.
Munster recorded a decisive 32-7 win over Benetton Treviso, although there was little of the free-flowing rugby that defined the Leicester match. It was a testament to Munster’s grit, grind and pack strength that they were able to slosh their way to victory in appalling conditions at Thomond Park. All four of their tries came from very close range with BJ Botha, CJ Stander, Duncan Casey and Simon Zebo burrowing over to win Munster a bonus point. Treviso’s only respite was a charge-down try from No8 Braam Steyn.
At Franklin’s Gardens, Northampton were visited by the Scarlets and scratched their way to a 15-11 win. Ken Pisi and Alex Waller were most deserving of their tries and Pisi’s fifty metre break was also instrumental in setting up a ‘try that never was’ for Luther Burrell. Scarlets were unable to capitalise on a pair of Northampton sin-binnings and missed 4 attempts at goal that would have seen them start the tournament off with a victory. Having said that their solitary score was a lovely team effort finished off by World Cup star Gareth Davies, and a losing bonus point is at least a small reward for their endeavour.
Saracens were able to defeat an understandably out-of-sorts Toulouse side 32-7 in their first Champions Cup match of the season. Given the awful conditions at Allianz Park it was commendable that 17 of Sarries’ points came from the boot of Owen Farrell, with a try from Mako Vunipola and a brace from Chris Wyles making up the total. Toulouse scored in the second half through substitution Chris Tolofua, and that concluded the scoring for the afternoon. Following Sebastien Bezy’s conversion on fifty one minutes neither team was able to contribute to the scoreboard and last year’s semi-finalists go top of Pool 1.
Sunday’s two games had three-time champions Leinster hosting Wasps at RDS and Exeter travelling to Liberty Stadium to take on Ospreys. In the first face-off, Wasps kicked into high gear to dispatch Leinster 33-6, the Irish side’s biggest ever home defeat, and looked convincing in the process, despite missing out on the winning bonus point. Their three tries ranged from fluky (Wade’s walk-in after a Dave Kearney slip) to clinical (Frank Halai’s break and offload to Joe Simpson) to downright bizarre (Sailosi Tagicakibau’s attempted try that bounced back into Charles Piutau’s hands) but Wasps were very effective in exploiting Leinster’s weaknesses and their successful season continues. Leinster meanwhile were rudderless and head coach Leo Cullen called it one of the worst days he has had at the club.
Exeter broke the English clubs’ run of success in the Champions’ Cup first round, losing 25-13 to Ospreys. The two teams contributed a try apiece but the story was written by Dan Biggar who recovered from a patchy first half performance and kicked 20 points to give Ospreys the win. Josh Matavesi’s opportunistic interception try capped off the afternoon. Rob Baxter was ‘annoyed’ with the Chiefs’ standard in this game, but will likely be focussing more closely on the Premiership this year, having fallen short in that area in previous season.
Champion’s Cup Star Man: Dan Biggar
Russian side make history with first European appearance
The second-tier competition of European rugby kicked off on Thursday with Harlequins v Montpellier, a showdown that Quins made look rather easy scoring 6 tries on the way to a 41-18 final score. Conor O’Shea’s side varied their play, hammering the French men with rolling mauls and close range offense that earned tries for four back-rowers, Easter, Clifford, Wallace and Robshaw, and Danny Care. Ollie Lindsay-Hague was beneficiary of a stunning team try started by the red-hot Marland Yarde; the winger also made a forty metre break with the very first touch of the match. Montpellier came up short in their quest for a try, instead relying on six penalties from Benoit Paillaugue.
Friday saw Edinburgh beat Grenoble 28-10 thanks to two Cornell du Preez tries and 11 points from Sam Hidalgo-Clyne, while Newcastle were unable to take anything more than a losing bonus point from their match against Brive, losing 13-9. Malakai Bakaniceva scored after 17 minutes for the French side and Newcastle couldn’t find a response with Tom Catterick kicking three penalties as their only points.
Saturday witnessed an historic afternoon in Siberia as Enisei-STM became the first Russian team to participate in a European rugby competition, although they couldn’t find a way to win their maiden outing against Connacht. The Irish side were facing temperatures of -18 degrees but earned a bonus point with their 31-14 win, while Enisei prop Andrei Polivalov will be the happiest of the Russian contingent after scoring 2 tries.
It was wins all round for Saturday’s English teams as Gloucester, Worcester and London Irish recorded victories of varying calibre. In their game against Zebre, the Cherry and Whites failed to improve on a 23-0 half-time lead, eventually running out 23-10 winners. Worcester made a positive start to their European return, beating La Rochelle 19-3 thanks to Ryan Lamb’s 14 points. A 77th minute try from Ben Howard sealed the deal for the Warriors. London Irish were by far the most convincing of the Premiership representatives in the Challenge Cup, dolling out an 8-try thrashing to Agen. Two tries each for hooker Gerard Ellis and Alex Lewington were supplemented by tries for Sean Maitland, Rob McCusker, Johnny Williams and Joe Trayfoot leading to an impressive 48-10 scoreline.
Cardiff Blues pounded Calvisano 50-9 and leapfrogged Harlequins to go top of Pool 3. Lloyd Williams and Tom James crossed before half-time with Ellis Jenkins and Dan Fish confirming the bonus point midway through the second period. Blaine Scully and Gavin Evans’ scores put the result beyond doubt and a 79th minute penalty try finished the Italians off. Sale experienced a hiccup in their promising early season losing to Newport Gwent Dragons 30-12 in the final match of the weekend. With Steve Diamond ringing the changes, the Sharks went behind early and in attempting to mount a comeback, were denied twice having crossed the line. Four tries for the hosts sees them get the full five points this week and top Pool 1.
Challenge Cup Star Man: Marland Yarde
Try of the Week: As ever, a tough decision to make, with plenty of exciting rugby played. It’s been a few weeks now that teams have had a quality score chalked off for some reason, and this weekend you have to see Luther Burrell’s try that was cancelled out by some George North foul play. Stade Francais put together a sensational move that was finished off by Julien Tomas but the pick of the bunch was definitely Ollie Lindsay-Hague’s try for Harlequins against Montpellier. It involves a great blend of individual flair and teamwork – skip to 1.50 below
Video credit: Total Rugby 2.0
Hero of the Week: It’s a bit of a cop-out I know, but I’m going to give the award this week to everyone who played in Connacht’s match against Enisei-STM. There are lots of layers to this one, first and foremost that the game was played in unbearably cold temperatures, to such an extent that the substitutions had to take extra precaution to keep warm on the sidelines. Just watching players get tackled on the snow covered pitch is enough to make you wince, and the inconsistent kicking is completely forgivable given the cold. Second, it was a history-making meeting, with Enisei the first Russian team to play in a European competition, and with any luck this will lead to the breakthrough of lesser-known teams from fringe rugby nations into the European rugby scene. Finally, we were treated to a brace of tries for a replacement prop which is always a delight, but it was also the first two Russian tries in European rugby history.
Villain of the Week: For a couple of reasons, George North has the ignominy of the Villain award this week. First he was seen stamping on Michael Tagicakibau, an ugly incident in any scenario but particularly unsavoury when it involves one of the sport’s stars. It continues North’s indifferent run of form with club and country, which is again a disappointment regarding how much he is capable of. Finally, it put paid to a brilliant try from Northampton which could have denied Scarlets the losing bonus point. For a foolish moment to deny his team a try and to hand a point to the opposition, North gets Villain of the Week.
By Fraser Kay (@fraserkay)
Photo by: Patrick Khachfe / Onside Images
Hate to sound like a broken record, and I am a fan of his, but this Dan Biggar hype is getting crazy. He was pretty dreadful yesterday in all facets of fly half play. His awful kick lead to the Exeter try. He missed three kicks at goal that I’d have made and the Ospreys back line didn’t ever look like firing off of him; only off loose Exeter kicks.
His up and unders to himself are brilliant, undoubtedly. But his basics as a fly half are far more important and he was poor in all fronts yesterday so I’m lost as to how he got MOTM (then again Stuart Barnes picked it and I’ve never placed much faith in anything he says), but now he was the best player in the Champions Cup all weekend? Absolute madness.
As a Wasps fan it was great to see them firing yesterday. I’m hoping we find a way to get Puitau to stay past this season, Ulster won’t mind surely!? Him, Daly and Halai were fantastic yesterday, as was Launchbury. Can see him growing into a leader within the Wasps squad as well which will code well for when he is given the England captaincy…
I had to turn the sound off so I didn’t realise he was man of the match. I don’t think he deserved it – distinctly average in the first half, but did improve after half time. In fact, I’d have ranked several Ospreys above him and whichever Exeter lock was making himself an almighty nuisance.
Damien Welch – brilliant at lock for Exeter. I agree, Dan Lydiate has a great game I thought, as did AWJ. Completely lost on me why Biggar was being lauded during that game.
Whilst I understand your point, I have in fact seen your kicking and not sure that your first statement is strictly true. Otherwise I do agree he is overhyped.
Wales should clearly drop Biggar and bring back James Hook or plead with Rhys Priestland not to take 18 months off international duty.
We all saw Biggar’s so so indifferent RWC 2015 and now a poor return to his region in the last fortnight.
Yeah so right there Jacob. Could not agree more.
Pehaps you failed to notice that even when Biggar made mistakes, his team still won and he gots MOM award and even player of the round on this page.
The prediction on this website b 4 the game was a 12 pts Exeter victory. What total nonsense.
This is yet again the usual pro-English view (before the event) that the Premiership Clubs are so very superior to all other sides from all of other nations.
It was taken as a given it seems, that with Exeter at 2nd in their league and the Ospreys way off the pace in theirs, then Exeter would just have to turn up at the Liberty to beat the home side by over 10 points and even deny the Ospreys a losing bonus point in the process.
After RWC 2015 you’d think a bit of humble pie would be served by those who follow English rugby but no…as usual its the view that
‘we are English and therefore automatically better than everyone else so there’.
Clearly the events of late Sept and early Oct 2015 passed you by.
Wouldn’t recommend dropping Biggar Enoch; he’s the best 10 you have. An extremely good 10 (as I did note in my post). However yesterday I thought he was incredibly poor.
Fortunately for him, his kicking performances in the WC (both from tee and out of hand) have led to him being heralded as a world class fly half. He is not.
As for a prediction for an Exeter win; did I make that? Not sure I did. And whoever did make it was perfectly entitled to do so. Exeter are a good side in form, and Ospreys were reintegrating a bunch of players returning from the WC, and therefore the performance levels were a bit of a guess. Fortunately for the Ospreys, their returning Welshman largely played very well (AWJ and Lydiate as I note above), however Biggar was not among them in my opinion.
Congrats on managing to bring a subjective opinion on the performance of a Welsh player back to digs about the state of England rugby – congrats, very impressive.
Enoch could make a comment about anything into a dig at England rugby. You just made it easy by starting on a linked subject like the performance of a Welsh rugby player.
Next time try making harder by starting on something random like Canadian ice hockey
But Leon didn’t those hated English once try to make Canada a colony, just like Wales……………………….!! Enoch could make anything into an anti English rant. Which is sad really as when he wasn’t commenting on Welsh or English games in the RWC he actually made some really good points. His problem not ours.